A Counsell/Wilson platoon will be better. To go along with terrible offense (and yes, last year was a fluke where Betancourt's HR/FB% was almost twice what it has been recently) Betancourt plays awful defense. Someone hitting like Betancourt but playing average defense (something of the floor of a Counsell/Wilson platoon) would be about a win better over a full season. EDIT:Yeah probably should stop the Yuni talk in this thread