No, the problem is you expect great players to be worth much more than they really are. An average player is about 2 WARs. A very good player is about 4 WARs. An All-Star is 4-5 WARs and an MVP is over 6. A win is huge amount. If you want to multiply it by 10 and call it runs, fine, but its just a measure of scale. EDIT: Think of it like GPA, Kendal with his 1.0 is a D student whereas Pujols with his 6.8 is acing all his honors courses and taking extra credits on top of it