Suppan has been as bad as everyone else. He's just been luckier. XFIP: Looper 4.52, Bush 4.86, Parra 4.94, Suppan 5.12 Now I personally think that while HR rates are more volatile they still have value so FIP: Parra 5.10, Looper 5.51, Suppan 5.52, Bush 5.87 Bush is the only one who you can somewhat expect to outperform his xFIP/FIP but his HR rate has to return to normal. The big question is why have the Brewer's pitcher been giving up so many HRs?