Poker, Poker, Poker. The perspective that gets lost in this type of debate as people tend to shoehorn (whether they intend to or not) others into 'win now' vs. 'complete the rebuild', is that Poker actually provides a pretty good model for thinking about team level strategy. Those players never tell themselves on seeing they've got pocket aces "that was a really good start, but I wasn't planning a move until later" Instead they understand (at the pro level) the role that luck plays, but also fully integrate the cards as they have been dealt. Undoubtedly we've been lucky, but a number of players have broken out so much (Thames is a clear case) that any preseason estimation of our talent level is just off which is part of the benefit of younger players some the 'luck' factor with them is not variation around established talent level it is these breakouts. So while we are not 'halfway' we are only 2 weeks from that point, and a 2 game lead 2 weeks from today probably translates conservatively into a 40% playoff chance which is worth raising a little bit to stay in the hand. Luckily we have plenty of young prospects to try out in many places and avoid big expensive trades (see first comment about breaking the dichotomy). But would I trade a Ryan Cordell for a solid middle reliever with a positive track record? Sure. Would I be willing to do a Billy Beane style buying and selling trade involving Braun that lands us a middle of the rotation starter and other bits and pieces. Sure