I mean.... no? The Pirates have had 4 winning seasons against the Brewers in the past 14 years. Two of those were 10-9. “Giving fits” doesn’t necessarily mean have a losing record. I am not good at locating stats, but I recall the other contenders in the division having a far better record vs. the Pirates than the Brewers did, making it that much more difficult for the Brewers to gain ground. I do remember the seasons when the Brewers dominated the Pirates, but those years are likely in the older years in your 14-year stretch. It’d be interesting to see the Brewers record vs. the Pirates compared to the rest of the division vs. the Pirates in the last decade. I’m assuming the 2011 Brewers did well against the Pirates as they did well against pretty much everyone.