If you were to take park effects into this discussion, and you should, you'd realize Bedard is significantly better than Peavey, and he doesn't have Peavey's horrible contract. So if a pitcher with great stuff fixes his mechanics and puts up big production, you will still ignore it? The type of player a guy is at age 23 will be what he is forever? Also, Scarpetta in the top 3? He isn't even in the discussion. If he doesn't start showing some improvement, he'll be repeating A ball. Thats bull. Butler opened last year BAs 17th ranked prospect in the Rays system. Your guy, Anundsen, has never made the Brewers top 31. I said it, not just that he throws harder, but that he has better stuff. If you don't think stuff matters in prospectum, then your going to be gravely disappointed. There is a huge list of pitchers who had poor stats in the low minors that turned out to be diminant, including some future HOFs. Theres also a ton of pitchers that put up good stats in the low minors, but turned out to be nothing because they pedestian stuff couldn't get out quality hitters. Being married to stats is what ruined the SD Padres. stats only tells part of the story.