I didn't reference a study, I posted a link to an article that suggest falacies in spring training cliches. You never referenced a study either though, that is my point. You referenced a generic comment on weight and athletics that had nothing at all to do with baseball or with power. Sure, if a player gained a ton of weight and it hurt him more than just HR hitting or if his stats suffered the entire year instead of just the first month and a half I could see it. There is nothing in Fielders stats that really suggests weight or diet preference had anything to do with his stats. My problem is really people saying that it is fact that his weight caused his power outage when there really is no proof at all that it is true. He lost a few HR, people looked for a reason why, they pointed at his weight and diet with no real proof behind it. Just seems much more likely to be random variation than anything else since like 20% of all baseball players fluctuate wildly year to year each season. If I have to rank why Fielder had an 'off year' I'd put it this way. 1) Random fluctuation of hot/cold streaks 2) Sophomore slump caused by trying to do too much (I know he's not technically a sophomore) 3) weather/offense being down/tougher pitchers faced than previous year etc. 4) Pissed about his contract status 5) Weight gain 6) Diet change As for Suppan I have been playing along with our season in DMB and after tomorrows game we are 4-2 and Suppan went 7 IP with 2 ER and we won the game including back to back HR by Braun and Fielder and a solo HR by Cameron later. So I'm confident!