Yeah that could be, but I'm not convinced FIP is any better than ERA as a stat. It is more consistent but since it ignores GB% and includes HR I think it is flawed. Basically FIP says the HR spike was bad but the HR spike didn't come with a FB% spike so it most likely was just a fluke caused by his injury. xFIP is a little bit better and that shows Suppan at a 4.91 which seems more realistic given his 4.86 in 2006 and 4.85 in 2007. Shandler's xERA is probably better too and that shows his trend as 4.44, 4.41, 4.59, 4.77, 4.87. He is getting worse with age but not nearly as much as it looked like from last years results.