Suppan strikes out a few more than Garland, Garland walks a few less, they are roughly the same in GB/FB. These two are very close to each other. If you use xFIP you see Garland with a trend of 5.15, 4.31, 4.82, 5.02, 4.65. Suppan has a trend of 4.73, 4.55, 4.86, 4.85, 4.91. These two guys are about as close to the same pitcher as you can get. Suppan K's a few more, Garland BB's a few less, otherwise they are twins.