Will win - Pedroia, Lee in AL. Howard, Lincecum in the NL Should win - Sizemore, Halladay in the AL (much more difficult teams faced overall than Lee), Pujols, Sabathia in the NL (not counting the AL numbers is silly given it is a tougher league). If you are sticking to your guns and saying Sabathia can't because of the split season I'd still pick Santana over Lincecum. If Braun doesn't get hurt I 100% believe he wins the NL MVP.