Well, you're talking about players you are pretty familiar with. Sherman likely isn't and depends on others to learn about them. Based on the story, he didn't even read the material at the MLB site about the Gallardo trade or thinks Melvin is BSing about Nelson. Lame. Sherman is writing the story and likely asks others about the Brewers. These are pretty common evaluations: Segura is just a 2nd division starter who can't hit; Gennett is a mediocre platoon bat and defense; Davis is a fringey 4th OF who can't take a walk; Braun is probably just an ok OF thanks to injury and/or no more vitamins; Lind is a platoon bat with bad defense; Ramirez is well into decline; Lohse is a 5th starter; Garza is a MOR guy who spends time on the DL every season; Fiers is a BOR pitcher and Nelson and Peralta are basically relievers thrust unwisely into starting roles who might be all right. You have to throw in the bullpen is awful (with no analysis) and the farm system is one of the worst and has no players ready to contribute this season. Lucroy and Gomez are nice players but both are likely to take a step back this season. None of those are unusual opinions. Meanwhile projection systems have the Cards rocking and rolling. Molina 33, Peralta, 33, Holliday 35 and Wainwright 33 are all expected to be big contributors. Heck, Jay will be 30 during the season and Carpenter is 29. If Adams, Wong and Bourjos were Brewers, the discussion of their warts would make them sound as if they could fly broomsticks. What could go wrong? And nobody talks about their window because... uh... they've got Marco Gonzalez and Randall Grichuk. I like the Pirates offseason, but they've got, as the kids say, high beta all over the place. But its easy to dream on more things breaking right than wrong and there is intense belief that Searage and Hurdle can adjust and change players to maximum performance. They're the darling of the media. Nobody is going to go looking for flaws. Cubs could be the only team to have more sizzle. The only difference is people give them a year before they begin their dynasty. That's how you end up with Joel Sherman.