I want to start by saying that I'm not against replay when it can be reasonably implemented. Like many have pointed out though, that's easier said than done. In response to this post, do you feel cheated and want your money back when the ball takes a funny "in-between" hop that one of our guys can't grab? Or when the wind is blowing strongly in and turns what would've been a home run into a fly out? The umpires are currently part of the game, like it or not, and no human being is perfect. It's part of the luck of the game whether any one close call does or doesn't go your way, just like in those other circumstances. I can understand being unhappy that your team lost on a tight call, but that wouldn't make me so angry that I'd want my money back, it's just bad luck. I'd be frustrated for sure, but no more so than I would be for a weird bounce of the ball or something like that. If anything, I'd get angry that we couldn't capitalize on one more opportunity to make that one call not even matter. While many may think the Brewers lost due to a terrible call, the terrible call will be one of many things that caused the Brewers to lose. It'd be the on-field performance that I paid to see that would make me want my money back, if anything. I don't oppose replays, I just completely disagree with the notion that it needs to be implemented so that people don't feel screwed by one call. Blaming one ump/call is a conveneint excuse people might use to make themselves feel better about the loss. It's blaming some outside force and not poor play that caused the loss. And also, while Jim Joyce obviously felt terrible, I think that in the long run he'll look back on this experience fondly. He'll realize that he basically did witness a perfect game, and while it was a very inconvenient time to make the wrong call, he'll remember Gallaraga's positive reaction and when Gallaraga brought him the lineup card the next day. I'm sure that means very much to him. After he gets over the initial agony of blowing the call, I would guess he'll have good memories of this time.