Starting May is a defensible decision. I thought after seeing him hit 99, the plan was to have him only go 2 or 3. Having him give up 2 runs, which still were pretty hard fought runs, wasn't the end of the world. When he gave up that moonshot I was certain he wasn't coming back out. Comes out and looks wild as hell. It was just dumb.
That said, this forum's steadfast defense of an awful pitcher who joined the team well past his prime and did nothing but suck is honestly incredible. I'd expect this treatment of like a washed up Yovani Gallardo, but the inability of some to just admit he's been an absolute flop is completely mystifying. He absolutely shouldn't be on an LCS roster if there is one.