This year, for the Pro Bowl? Yes, it's not close. Rodgers has a top 10 OL this season. He has Aaron Jones and Adams. Yes the WR group is thin after him, but there is plenty that looks diminished about Rodgers to think he's not the guy he used to be. Rodgers has a better passer rating by 1 point and trails in QBR and yards by 20 and 1000. The Pro Bowl is supposed to be this year's achievements, not your career. Of course it never is that. Favre got named to the game in several flat-out poor seasons. Rodgers isn't there yet, but no, he's not a top 3 QB in the NFC this season. We're talking about the Pro Bowl, not the MVP. The rest of the roster shouldn't be relevant. Rodgers look about as magical as Favre did at this point. Still good, and far less turnover prone, but clearly someone that needs quality support everywhere and can't take over games by himself.