Sorry, I must disagree. Just since 2000, you've got guys like Dilfer, Brad Johnson, Joe Flacco, and Nick Foles as average guys. and Russell Wilson/Patrick Maholmes on rookie contracts. That's six super Bowls of the last 21 or 30%. There'll be a lot of debate about the level of play out of guys like Eli Manning or Roethlisberger, but they're NOT elite-level QBs, so that's another 4. Basically, 48%, or half of the recent Super Bowls have been won by either young QB's or non-elite level guys. It's all about the team you put around the guy most of the time, and being on a rookie contract gives you a better chance to put a championship-caliber team on the field. Your group of QB that got you to 30% confuses me. Dilfer, Johnson, and Foles were all past their rookie contract and would be considered average QBs at best. Wilson and Maholmes were on rookie contracts and are HOF probable QBs. Flacco was a rookie and an average QB overall. So are you looking for inexpensive contracts here? You also missed 2x when Tom won on his rookie contract. If you want to look at low cost QBs vs high cost, I think that comes down to 10 of 22 (Brady 2x, Rothlisberger, Wilson, E Manning, Mahomes, Flacco as rookies and Dilfer, Johnson, and Foles/Wencz as "inexpensive"). So that is 45%, which is still less likely than winning with a high priced, HOF level QB (55%). I'd agree that neither Eli Manning or Ben are elite QBs, but that wasn't my qualifier. I had to draw a line and HOF (while not great) does show delineation of skill sets from other QBs; especially when compared to Foles, Johnson and Dilfer. So I'll stick to my mantra - if you don't have a HOF level QB, go get one; if you have one, build around him as much as possible. Since dumping a HOF level QB in hopes that Love or some one else will reach that level (or just luck out...) seems like a foolish choice given how difficult it is to find excellent QBs. BTW, the numbers came from one very boring day when I sat down and made a spreadsheet of the SB winning/losing QBs and looked up when they finished their rookie contracts, so I'm not just WAG-ing numbers.