I was annoyed because you were refuting my own statement by telling me to go look up more stats. If you want to use those stats, please provide them. I'm not disagreeing they are valuable, I just don't have access to them. I'm confident in my own evaluation of watching him play last year that he was very hot for the first half of the season and dropped off massively the second half. Sacks aren't everything in the evaluation, but they aren't nothing either. His sack drop-off aligned with what I saw on the field and I'd bet his pressures did exactly the same. I thought he might be dropping into coverage more than last year, but this article says that he dropped into coverage exactly the same as the first 5 games of last year: What grading system? Our run defense has been so attrocious, I've not thought about Smith in this regard. But he has been increasingly reminding me of Nick Perry (minus the injury issues), who was strong against the run and had one good year in pass rush. Yes, as I looked back, he was better than I gave him credit for. He had more pressure plays where he didn't get the sack, but someone did. But even if he plays that way the whole season, I doubt he will be worth the $16M cap number. Between the 4 FAs they signed last year, I'd be surprised if at least one of them isn't cut this year for finance reasons. Smith has Gary behind him (granted both are getting high amount of snaps now) and has been the least valuable so far this year.