I could see Thames as a Tier 2 guy, but I think it's unfair to compare him to Carter. Thames still gets on base very well, Carter didn't . Actually, Carter obp was .100 higher than his batting average (he hit .222), which is a lot better than most of this team. The Thames of May/June (pitchers figured where to pitch?), is starting to look very much like 2016 Carter, except without the slugging. Maybe the Reds haven't updated their book on Thames yet.