Chapman is the wildcard in this discussion. He could be poised to be on a level of Randy Johnson (or not, but he does have filthy stuff). If Chapman becomes one of the best in baseball like I think he might become, then its tough to say. The Cardinals staff is maybe more proven than the Brewers staff. On potential alone the Brewers staff is likely the #3 staff in the NL behind the Phillies & Giants (I think Lincecum is the best player in baseball, stats be damned, the Freak is a freak in the clutch) but potential doesn't win you Championships. I think Marcum will likely surprise many (but not me) and post an ERA around 2.87 ... If Gallardo can pitch like we all know he is capable of, for a full season, and if Greinke pitches like the Cy Young type ace he's capable of, the Brewers will go very far (still alot of "ifs") The thing is, the Brewers have more hitting than just about anyone. We don't actually even need all of our pitchers to have career years to go deep into the playoffs