What exactly have Broxton or Flores done when they've gotten playing time? Been flat out horrible is about it. And it's not like Kirk is old either, at 28 he's in his prime. I can't imagine Counsell going to Kirk and saying "Sorry, we're benching you for a guy who's OPS'ing almost 200 points lower than you or another guy who's OPS isn't even above the Mendoza line." Ya, play the young guys but don't play the worse player just because he's younger.