Reacting not to PBIB specifically but to the sentiments/slants expressed, which some folks do believe to be truth based on comments that continue to surface.... The first sentence above is correct. The rest isn't. - The Brewers did offer him the chance to pitch out of the pen, which he declined. - They encouraged him to stay with the team. They didn't send him home, let alone tell him to stay there. - It was Garza who chose to leave the team. He wasn't going to pitch again and his wife was late in her pregnancy with twins. I'd guess the Brewers would've preferred that Garza make different choices than he did, starting with accepting the chance to pitch out of the pen just like Lohse did. But at least in terms of how the whole episode was reported (publicly, anyway), Garza didn't go against any team mandates and chose options that the team made available to him or otherwise allowed. I'm not too keen on Garza, but it skews the picture to portray it inaccurately. I'd also guess that the Brewers know they're on the hook for two more years with a guy who, (uncontrolled/unclassy/immature?) petulance notwithstanding, has a good arm and a very solid track record, so it does them no good to do anything other than hope for the best out of him going forward -- the exact slant Counsell & the front office have voiced publicly. Same as Braun, people have already made up their minds about what they believe happened and nothing will change that.