Does this make the Brewers a better team today? Yes Does this increase the likelihood that the Brewers make the playoffs? Yes Does this increase the likelihood that the Brewers might win a game in the playoffs? Yes Does this make the Brewer a better team for next year? Nope My initial disappointment with the trade is not getting controllable talent for next year. Maybe the Orioles wanted too much for either/both of Gaussman and Schoop... Rentals do have a benefit and the prospects we gave up are not in the Brantley/Cruz category of ceiling... Phillips has a hole in his bat the size of a watermelon and Bat holes are the hardest to fix... If defense will be effected, but the difference from (Shaw-2B) + (Mouse-Shaw) > any other combination we have and as pointed out, the Brewers use a lot of IF shifting so I expect on some occasions Mouse & Shaw will be side-by side and Arcia will be covering most of the 2B side... Overall we may lose a few DP and give up a few more singles in the hole, but with some creative placement of the IF we can minimize the defensive issues... Mouse gives us another high OPS/low OBP bat so if we get a team hot streak starting game 163, who knows... Long-term, we will have both Burnes and Peralta in the rotation mix for next year and, hopefully, a fully recovered Jimmy Nelson. We will still need to upgrade 2B/C/SS and as I pointed out in another thread, there are a ton of FA 2B coming and there are a few options at C on the FA market for upgrades to either of those 2 positions, so I am more comfortable kicking those issues down the road...