On that note, let's review his July: 2 "good" starts (7/18 and 7/23) 3 "not-so-good" starts (7/8, 7/13, 7/28) 1 "inconclusive" start (7/3) Since you've conceded August, let's go right on ahead to June: 1 "good" start 1 "inconclusive" start And May: 2 "good" starts (5/7, 5/28) 3 "not-so-good" starts (5/13, 5/18, 5/23) and of course, 1 "inconclusive" start (5/2) That's 3 months right there that Capuano was not exactly very good. I'm excluding June since he was injured. And let's review the second half of 2006: July (post-All Star Break): 2 "good" starts (7/21, 7/31) 2 "not-so-good" starts (7/15, 7/26) August: 4 "good" starts (8/11, 8/16, 8, 22, 8/27) 1 "not-so-good" start (8/6) September: 3 "good" starts (9/1, 9/6, 9/18) 3 "not-so-good" starts (9/13, 9/23, 9/29) Let's be honest, if the Brewers are to compete this year, they need a more consistently-good effort out of their starting pitching. And for the past season and a half now, Capuano has failed to answer the bell start in and start out. And the Brewers can ill-afford to throw him in the rotation with the hopes that he'll do better overall. It's maddening seeing Capuano have good games and then a bunch of bad ones. But, unfortunately, it emphasizes his overall inconsistency. And that is why it'd be a gamble to put him into the rotation. EDIT: And this pretty much supports my point as to why having him in the rotation is not a good idea.