Well, one of those things happened for sure. The other is debatable. How is it debatable? I admit I missed the game last night (partly for my own sanity and partly because I was out with friends)...but looking at the line he pitched 7 innings, and gave up only 5 hits and 3 walks, and of course no runs. Sounds pretty decent to me. The three walks all came in the same inning as he loaded the bases with a 6 run lead on walks. This moment ruined his start IMO, even though he got out of it without any damage.