I am a big Doug Melvin supporter and apologist, but his inability to solve the 1b problem is very irritating. We suffered through a historically bad year at 1b with guys like Halton, Maldanado, Yuni B, Blake Lalli, Alex Gonzalez and Juan Francisco. Lucroy played there some, but removing him from behind the dish makes him far, far less valuable and frankly I see no difference between Maldanado playing 1b or C with Lucroy is also in lineup at he other position. Now we are back facing the EXACT same problems at the EXACT same position the very next year. We have Overbay on the team but he cant even get starts over Lucroy right now. I dont claim to offer solutions, but I think we can all agree that there is a problem that needs to be fixed and it needs to happen soon.