i dont get all the hate for May. The pieces they gave up were expensive but nowhere near what we'd have lost for Skubal.
The market for pitchers was pricey at the deadline. Why didnt they do it at a different time of year? Brewers have been very proactive in their deals in the offseason and earlier in the season. They went into this season with expectations for contributions from Woody, Priester, and Sproat that didnt materialize. They found themselves in a better than expected situation for the World Series and had to make some move and this was the best option.
Skubal deal only changes the outlook for public opinion, because it wouldve cost Henderson, plus, plus. So that was potentially a wash for THIS YEAR.
May deal had ZERO downside for THIS YEAR's TEAM. They lost some longterm prospects and hat to cut loose some scrubs.
May is a better option for this year's team than Sproat and he can go longer into games and eat some innings.. and he's experienced. That all helps. The team needed another top-4 pitcher and they have that in May.
Plus, there have been enough questions with the health and longevity of Harrison and Henderson around the deadline that we couldnt risk riding 3 young guys for 1-2-3 in the playoffs.
We dont know yet where May lands in the playoff rotation, but it could be anywhere 2-4.