Who has the better ceiling as a Starter? Jimmy Nelson or Tyler Thornburg? Or is it about equal? Who has a better ceiling as a Starter? Thornburg or Garza? Thornburg or Estrada? It's known that Thornburg's FB drops what? 3-4MPH as a Starter vs. as a Reliever. Play him out of the bullpen, not just for this year, but beyond. This can be our Closer of 2015. KRod is a 1year deal. Henderson is already losing faith. So honestly, looking in to the future, who steps up in to the closer role? All things being the same, Nelson or Thornburg as Starters, just go with Nelson as the plan for now and Thornburg remains your Bullpen guy for the future. If Thornburg does go in to the Closer's role next year, his future payday will increase far,far quicker than if he's a Starter, so I don't see why he wouldn't want that if the team is proposing the idea towards him? We have Pitching depth of #3s, it really shouldn't matter which of the collective of 3s are on the mound so long as they do their job. Arguing against Estrada being on the mound because his future isn't long in Milwaukee anymore? So let's reduce his value by demoting in the Pen, just to put Thornburg out there who's tossing 3-4MPH slower on his FB? Because Thornburg has a longer future with the team? Where's the logic in that? With that logic, Gallardo should be in the Bullpen for sure since he stands to be gone after this season. The team is set up the way it is set up, for at least this season and maybe next if Gallardo's option is picked up. Why grumble about Thornburg being in the bullpen? vs. Starting every 5 days? If Thornburg truly is good enough to take the mound every 5 days effectively, his time will come a year from, 2 years, 5 years, whatever it may be. He'll force it behind his talent. He can voice his displeasure too at some point and the team can address that when it happens with either making a move to get him what he wants. Or trading him to a team who wants him as a starter. I'm just glad that one of our own prospects is 1 healthy and 2 performing at a high level. A level that helps this team win(He's 2-0 and I don't know why he doesn't have a save from completing that other game?)