Okay going off MLB's top 10 LHP/RHP. LH:Heaney no, Owens yes, Fried yes, Biddle yes, Urias no, Rodriguez yes, Nicolino yes, Escobar yes, Ball yes, Ray yes. RH: Bradley no, Walker no, Syndergaard no, Gray...I'd mull about it, Appel yes, Stephenson yes, Bundy yes, Taillon yes, Sanchez no, Zimmer yes. You're complaining about 17mil a season for a 5WAR player? What's 1WAR worth? 5mil? or 25mil in production for 17mil salary? Beltre is the kind of hitter that can flat out win series for you. In a 7game series he could go 10-30 with 5HRs 12RBI. When he's locked in, there's almost nobody better than him. (there may not be) For Milwaukee's current roster makeup the return on winning a World Series can supercede the cost of giving up your future SP. Again he's just that valuable of a hitter. I'm not going to get caught up with his age when he's a .300 hitter 30HR power with a .350s/60s OB. If Beltre wasn't the kind of hitter that can carry you through a series then obviously the trade is a bad idea. This would be replacing Reynolds/Overbay at 1b with ARam taking 1b duties...supposedly. Reynolds' bat will disappear come playoff time when he's facing #1,2,3s of Playoff contending teams. The HR that keeps him remotely valuable will turn in to 4-30 7game series with 21Ks 1HR 1RBI. And then you'll wonder why you didn't get Beltre when there was the opportunity to get him leaving the black hole bat of Reynolds in your playoff lineup to just get dominated at a time you needed him most. If you're playing to win a World Series you gotta do what's best to make that happen. If you're not concerned with playing for a World Series on a given season but just to cycle a continual competitive team than you never trade away your best prospects. Yeah Tampa has 6 straight winning seasons 5 of them 90+Win seasons. But just 1 World Series appearance in 2008. That year? Not one trade for the stretch run. Not 1 batter with a .300+BA. 2010, 96 wins. They acquired Chad Qualls a RP. Longoria/Crawford were approx .300 hitters, nobody else was above .265 on the season. 2011, No trades again. Last year they acquired David Dejesus for the late stretch run as an upgrade in the OF(and atop the order vs Jennings) over Sam Fuld/Kelly Johnson/Matt Joyce. It's great what Tampa has been able to do as an organization with their payroll. But they haven't won the World Series. The year they win the World Series will be the year they find that impact player the team was missing. Sacrificing say 4-6wins a year for the next 5years to get the 4 wins that matter the most.