Well, for one, he has only played for about 2 months - he was hurt for a long time. His bat is coming around over the past 3 weeks, though. Right, he was very rusty early on but he's been very solid at the plate lately. I'm very aware of how he's doing as he's on my fantasy team(or will be until I trade him as I won't roster a filthy cub) and has been starting regularly for me. I know I made an anti-Theo comment previously...but reality is they gave up nothing for a month and playoffs of this guy, and Murphy is going to be good down the stretch. This was a no brainer move for them and basically a zero risk move. If he sucks, don't play him. Rosters expand in 2 weeks, worst case scenario Murphy goes cold and you bench him and you wasted a couple bucks.