It's amazing how many years we can watch Badgers FB, watch players wildly exceed expectations and then just declare with this level of certainty what will happen... In fact, I would almost guarantee that you'd have said the same when Tolzien took over in 2009 before leading the Badgers to 21 wins and a 2 PT conversion away from a top 3 national ranking. I haven't actually watched Coan in Spring Practice or camp, so I won't guess how he's progressed, but It'd be foolish enough to write him off. Especially with the talent around him. All he has to do is be a competent passer. We have good receiving options, he has a strong arm and Taylor and the running game makes the job far easier. Do people really not remember that Hornibrook led us to a 13-1 record and a TD away from getting into the playoffs in the B10 Championship game? I didn't watch the Badgers in 2009, so no, I would almost guarantee I didn't. I mean strong wording to say Hornibrook led them anywhere. The defense led them there and running game ran the offense. Unless by default you just give the QB leadership credentials. In my opinion Coan doesn't have the sheer talent level to take over an offense and lead it...Mertz does, but he is also a freshman and producing is a way different ball game than just having the talent. Coan is basically a guy who is sent out there and be average...that's what you hope for because with Taylor and their running game that will make the offense great. Sure maybe Coan magically changed over the offseason...but unlikely.