If Melvin traded players anywhere near the rate you people want he would have lost his fanbase years ago. How? People have never suggested trading anyone in the prime of their careers when they are still affordable unless that player is playing over his head and his value is likely to go way down. What we've essentially suggested is doing what he did with Zack Greinke, but doing it more often. Did the fan base go nuts when we traded Greinke? Of course not, because most people knew it was the best move. I don't think anyone will complain about how the Greinke situation played out. Trading Corey Hart would have been the same thing. Making moves based on what the fan base wants is foolish. Someone has a good year trade him ASAP and play for 2 years from now! STAT! Last years bullpen was mediocre at best going into the season, trading Axford would have just been foolish No it was not. Going into the season the bullpen was supposed to be a strength, with Axford, KRod, Lowe and Braddock. It ended up being a disaster and Axford was a major reason why. You could have gotten an elite prospect or two for Axford after 2011. Now you just have to hope he can come even close to what he did two years ago. Like I said, people have never suggested trading away guys like Weeks, Braun or Fielder in the primes of their career. But when it comes to guys like Axford, whose major league success seems to have come out of nowhere, maximizing his value wouldn't be the worst thing in the world. I'm sorry but for the most part closers are a dime a dozen. Replacing him wouldn't be nearly as difficult as replacing a Greinke or a Marcum. So if you can get a #2 potential pitcher by trading a reliever you have to at least consider it. And I'm sorry but sometimes teams like the Brewers have to play for "2 years from now". We can't go all in every year and look no further than this year to see why. We've gone all in the past 2 years and now it's time to come back to earth a little bit. Luckily our pitching prospects advanced right when we needed them too, but if Rogers had another setback or Fiers didn't pitch lights out we'd be looking at another rotation with guys similar to Braden Looper and Randy Wolf. Sometimes you need the prospects because they are going to build your core, cheaply, for 4 or 5 years.