I believe that I am asked, as a fan, to form attachments to these players. Buy their jerseys, cheer them on. Then, I need to put those feelings aside and say, "No, you can't re-sign this guy. Don't pay for the decline." I can't do that. He is becoming a top-5 all-time Brewer for me. The video of him on the ground, telling Frelick to slide in Game 2 of the SD series is a favorite moment.
I would love to see William extended. Damn the torpedoes, full speed ahead. I'd give him 5 years. Tear up next year's contract (15.5 mil), give him 5/100 (essentially 4/84.5). Takes him through his age 33 season. Get him a 1B glove for a few games a year and plan on DHing him a little more after Yelich is gone.