Heading into the last game of his third season, Murphy is doing something historic. Even including his 96-game interim gig with the Padres in 2015 (42-54 record), he has crept into the top 25 in baseball history in winning percentage. His Brewer gig alone puts him just outside the top 10. That's in all of baseball history. According to Baseball Reference, here are the numbers:
#Seasons
Wins
Losses
Pct.
1
Bullet Rogan HOF
5
258
111
0.699
2
Vic Harris
11
637
322
0.664
3
Andy Cooper HOF
4
208
114
0.646
4
Rube Foster HOF
7
341
194
0.637
5
Dave Malarcher
7
267
159
0.627
6
Frank Warfield
6
238
145
0.621
7
Dave Roberts
12
1043
638
0.62
8
Joe McCarthy HOF
24
2125
1333
0.615
9
Jim Mutrie
9
658
419
0.611
10
Charlie Comiskey HOF
12
839
540
0.608
MURPHY AS BREWER MANAGER
3
292
193
0.602
11
Frank Selee HOF
16
1284
862
0.598
12
Billy Southworth HOF
13
1044
704
0.597
13
Bill Joyce
3
179
122
0.595
14
Frank Chance HOF
11
946
648
0.593
15
John McGraw HOF
33
2763
1948
0.586
16
Al Lopez HOF
17
1410
1004
0.584
17
Aaron Boone
9
790
565
0.583
18
Earl Weaver HOF
17
1480
1060
0.583
19
Mickey Cochrane HOF
5
348
250
0.582
20
Harry Wright HOF
23
1225
885
0.581
21
Cap Anson HOF
21
1295
947
0.578
22
Eddie Dyer
5
446
325
0.578
23
Pants Rowland
4
339
247
0.578
24
Fred Clarke HOF
19
1602
1181
0.576
25
Pat Murphy
4
334
247
0.575
He's done it in baseball's smallest market, at a time when the disparity between the haves and have-nots has never been greater, with one of the youngest rosters in MLB. He has worked with rookies, established vets, waiver wire acquisitions, minimum salaried players, etc. He and the front office have managed the Nashville shuttle and the 40-man, and done it with a brand of baseball that maximizes the margins and leverages market inefficiencies.
Our opponents and their fans are befuddled by the Brewers' success, and a lot of the credit has to go to Murphy. There are a good number of posters who think he can't build lineups, is poor at managing a bullpen, bad at in-game replacements, don't like how he calls out players, hate him bringing his kids to pressers, but you cannot deny the winning. Outside of Aaron Civale (and Jesse Winker), have we heard of players unhappy within the org even after they leave? Some posters like to imagine that certain decisions won't go over well in the clubhouse but can't point to any concrete evidence of it.
He's the perfect manager for this organization, and this team. Now go win it all!