Well, Thames is terrible .... like substantially worse than Smoak this year. I don't get why so many Brewer fans miss the guy. He was average for a couple years here, and had some nice moments, but dropping him was no loss at all. ANd Moose signed a monster deal with the Reds. Thames has a -.0.2 WAR and 55 OPS+ this year Smoak has a -0.3 WAR and 88 OPS+ this year Smoak has been the better hitter, but both have been equally worthless in different ways. I don't miss Thames, but Smoak hasn't been substantially better. And Smoak is substantially cheaper than Thames's option would have been this year.