Those guys would look a lot better if Yelich and Hiura were hitting. The quality you are getting with the likes of Smoak, Sogard, Holt and Narvaez is not substantially less than you got with Moose, Grandal and Thames. I would bet the ranch that a platoon of Sogard and Gyorko and Holt won’t produce anything close to what Moustakas did last year. Last season’s production at 3B was dragged down by Shaw, and Moustakas’ contributions were spread between 2B and 3B. I don’t see Smoak matching Thames or Navarez matching Grandal either. The Brewers had basically a league average offense last season and this year’s figured to be significantly below average, even if Yelich produced at something close to expectations. As he hits like a poor hitting pitcher it’s a really bad offense. I liked Moose as well, but his impact really seems to be a bit overinflated among this fanbase. Still, I will give you that the Sogard/Gyorko/Holt platoon is not as good as Moose. But when you compare apples to apples, you have to combine Moose/Shaw, then it gets a lot closer. Shaw was that terrible last year. Thames and Smoak have basically been the same player throughout their careers. Thames is another guy who is probably a little overinflated because he had several "hero ball" moments, but the fact is that he was simply an average 1B. Narvaez may be a step down from Grandal, but judging by the numbers he's put up the last few seasons, that step should not be significant. We haven't necessarily seen it yet, but the guy is a good player. What the Brewers did this offseason is go out and acquire players who they felt would be able to combine to provide similar production to what they gave up, at a much cheaper price point, likely because they knew that they'd be working on the Yelich extension. It isn't like the 2019 offense was some kind of juggernaut. They had stretches where they looked terrible.