As in you think Broxton/Santana would be superior players? Cleveland is in a weird spot. They got aggressive with several years of control on Hand/Cimber, but they can probably wait out the outfield trades and probably go pretty cheap there. Their 2018 season opens about 70 days from now. I think if the Brewers and Indians were going to get together on an OF trade, it would have happened in the offseason or in spring training. The Indians are a good match for Broxton and a great match for Santana. But they decided to go with junk OFers instead, and it has bitten them. However, in that time, Santana and Broxton have turned in junk performances as well, so who knows? In any case, I bet they get Adam Jones for next to nothing.