It's hard to blame Melvin that much for Hall. He had two good years in a row, and he had improved each year. It's hard to imagine that a guy in his mid 20's (at that point) was going to regress so badly in just a couple years. I mean, he's not even 30 yet and has just completely fallen off as far as production. Plus, while I realize his contract is somewhat of a handcuff from making moves, it's not like it was the most abysmal contract ever. Only owed $8 million or so next year, so I don't think you can really blame that for lack of future moves this off-season. As far as Suppan, they needed a steady pitcher badly at that point. I don't know how much influence Attanasio had...I'm sure some, since he wined and dined Soup before the signing. However, if Melvin really thought it was going to turn out this badly, he should have edged Attanasio away. I admit I liked the signing at the time, as it was nice to see the Brewers going to free agency to address a serious need. However, in retrospect it's obvious they should not have made the move. The prospect of Soup being on this staff again next year is down right scary. I seriously wonder if they might either trade him for next to nothing, or just DFA the guy. He just isn't keeping the team in games on any consistent basis anymore.