Fair enough. Melvin really hasn't done much to improve our ballclub this year. With the fact that (as stated above) we have two massive contracts with little to no real value eating up 24% of our payroll, we also gave away 1 million to Julio (who looked like crap in ST, and we finally dropped). 2010, we are possed for much of the same until we free up 24% of our roster. We have severally over paid for pitching, and it's not so much we rolled 'them bones and gambled for a win, we rolled them bones for 5 years on a gamble that stats that indicate a regression some how break from tendency and improve. Add into it how he divorced ourselves from one of the best pitchers in baseball (Sheets when healthy.. yeah yeah, still doesn't excuse the fact that the bridge is sooo burned by Melvin). He was extremely reluctant to fire Yost, now brings in Macha who appears to be perhaps equally Yostian, he then engages Deputy Braun in the media (He should rise above and not make the situation worse). This clubs success was based on drafting, we had our window for the past 3 years and Melvin was unable to fill the gaping holes in our lineup to compliment our farm talent. That window is closing in 2010 when we'll see massive salary increases for these players, so we'll trade them away. Our rise to contender wasn't due to brilliant Beane-esk moves, it has to do with our farm club talent becoming just that talent. I'm not saying Melvin wasn't the person for the job before, but like Yost, he was fine getting us to a point, but now we needed to take a step further. And Melvin hasn't delivered. (Please no more CC stuff)