Probably not . I would agree that their current values are fairly similar. His defense at 2nd is below average, his range is non-existent and he's not versatile in any real way. Much is made of his 2017 season, but it wasn't THAT great. Much of his power surge can likely be attributed to GABP. I wouldn't expect him to replicate those power totals ever again. All that aside, he was only a 2.3 fWAR player, which is probably close to his ceiling, while his floor is replacement level. That's not very exciting. Don't get me wrong, he was far better than Villar in 2017 but that doesn't mean he'll be better going forward. I'd be neither excited nor disappointed if we traded Villar for Gennett.