I believe this line of thinking is a bit flawed. For a team of 4 Ruths and 5 Koufax's that may very well be the best lineup. However, the Brewers aren't made up of 4 Ruth's and 5 Koufax's (more like 8 Ruth's and one Koufax). The point being, every team is not made of the average lineup. If the arguement is that the #3 hitter comes up most with 2 outs, nobody on, couldn't an arguement then be made to put your pitcher in that spot? Of course, no manager would ever do that. My personal preference it to get your best hitters as many AB's as possible. I would probably have the top 3 be Weeks, Braun, Fielder. I would also have the pitcher bat 9th for the same reasoning. Anything else is overthinking, and opens the manager up to too much second guessing.