There isn't really anything to suggest that Escobar will not outhit Hardy. It's not like it would take that much to do so anyways. Hardy, MLB - .659 OPS, .737 Career Escobar, AA - .723 OPS To say that Escobar, who's hitting about the same against AA pitchers as JJ is against MLB pitchers, will outhit him in the majors right now is just an odd thing to say. Also, Hardy plays fine defense. There wouldn't be that great of an improvement, if any at all, other than range. Which is, like, half the equation. Hardy's good, but Escobar's great, they say. It would be stupid to bring him up now, he won't be an improvement - probably not even in 2009. 2010 is probably Escobar's debut as a regular.