I'm 100% against making it "kid only". I understand the sentiment, but there are plenty of adult fans who want an autograph too. I'm not talking about the hard core collectors either, I'm talking about the regular guy (or girl) who thinks, "a JJ Hardy signed ball would be really cool". Nothing wrong with that. As for my thoughts on the randomness thing. It's certainly not perfect, but I think it's better than the chaos that they have now. No assigned players, just 10 lines (or whatever number) and you get in line not knowing who is coming. Yes, it would suck for people like you and I who want certain items signed by certain players. However, for the people who, as Turbo points out, just want an autograph for their kids it's fine. No stampedes, just lines (and a surprise autograph). Granted, this is not a particularly well thought idea. It's just the first thing I thought of. I guess my thought is, it's free, so I can't complain (much). But who knows. Maybe I'll sit and think about it and decide I hate the idea too.