If your expectations were for a superstar CFer, Cameron is not going to "prove you wrong." That said, he has plenty of value. For one, you are seriously underestimating Camerson's defense. Even at 35, it's not just good, it's great. He has a reputation as one of the best defenders in the league and UZR (defense metric) has him as the best CFer so far this year. It doesn't take any fancy numbers to get a feel for how much value being able to track down a would-be gapper can have. As for his stick, it's nothing special but it isn't bad either. His ZiPS projection (even after being updated with his bad current numbers) stands at .246/.334/.443./.776. For a guy who plays great defense, that plenty good. Of course, if you think a .776 OPS with lot's of strikeouts is significantly worse than one without alot of Ks, I could see how you might be underestimating his offensive value.