That looks pretty ugly, but play a game, if the guy does OK, keep him in that batting slot and fielding position. If he doesn't do well, select a new random guy. Your random lineup just benched one of the only guys hitting at all (Hart) and put one of the wiorst hitters on the team in the 3 hole (Gwynn). What's one game going to prove anyway? A week doesn't really tell you anything, afterall. Any baseball fan knows that anything can happen over the short term. If people want to swap the lineup around just for the heck of it, I don't have a problem with it, since it's not too important anyway. But to start benching good hitters for bad ones for the sake of change is a bad idea. It's easier to pitch to contact then it is to strike out a batter when you're down 2-0, 3-1. I've never been sure what people mean when they say "pitch to contact". I think it is just used to describe a pitcher who doesn't strike many batters out. If you are a groundball pitcher you'll be OK with good defense. If you are a flyball pitcher, you are probably screwed. With the infield defense as it, trying to induce groundballs might not be a great idea anyway. And if pitching to contact simply entails throwing more of your off speed stuff as oppossed to your fastball, doing that when behind in the count will just mean more walks.