But you said it isn't true that he was incredibly streaky in 2017-18. That's where you are incorrect. He also put up a pretty terrible .698 OPS in August of his breakout 2017 season. He's always been a streaky hitter, prone to extended slumps. If he doesn't have that .OPS up above .700 by the end of May, then we have an issue. I think most players have "slumps" like that over a month. Shaw's slump is now going over three years.