The only reason that Gagne is getting the ball over DeFelice, is that Gagne is making $10M. To be fair, Gagne also has shown extreme effectiveness in the recent past, something worth taking a chance on, whereas DeFelice can be recalled at any time. I don't mind Melvin giving him another shot to show he can be an effective part of the pen. If he continues to allow runs (2 or 3 bad appearances) we can put him on waivers, but I think it's too soon right now, let's see what he does with, presumably, a clean bill of health. Gagne looked good at times so it's not like he can't get outs anymore. We will see. I just don't see it as a bad thing to take another shot with him. Just don't put him in the game with a 1-2 run lead right now.