Trade peralta

[Klantz27]

Miz patrick henderson myers quintana woodruff ashby hall rodriguez, gasser will be back later this year we have plenty of quality starting options 

I would look to trade peralta to the Nationals centered around 3b base prospect brady house 

It's been reported the nats priority is looking for an ace to pair with mckenzie gore if that's the case this trade would make sense 

Also cortes needs to go when he is healthy as well

[BrewerFan]

5 hours ago, Klantz27 said:

Miz patrick henderson myers quintana woodruff ashby hall rodriguez, gasser will be back later this year we have plenty of quality starting options 

I would look to trade peralta to the Nationals centered around 3b base prospect brady house 

It's been reported the nats priority is looking for an ace to pair with mckenzie gore if that's the case this trade would make sense 

Also cortes needs to go when he is healthy as well

Miz is going to give you... maybe 60 more innings this year and while his stuff is electric, he's not a finished product.
Henderson, same thing, though he's over-performed. He's a good #3 who also has maybe 60-70 innings left. 

They could be pushed a bit, maybe 140, but they're not taking the ball every 5 days. 
 
Myers is in AAA because he wasn't throwing the ball well.
Patrick is throwing the ball well. Probably not wise to expect him to maintain this level of performance as a rookie and as HE gets closer to a career high in innings. 
Quintana was a cheap back of the rotation pitcher who is a nice innings filler.

Hall hasn't been a trust starter. Any plans to turn Ashby into one appear to be on hold for yet another year. 
Rodriguez...back of the rotation arm.

And Woodruff, I hope he comes back like Ashby did lsat year and is back to throwing 97 later in the year, but he hasn't started a game yet. 

Gasser won't be back as a starter this year. He may come back and pitching in some capacity, but expecting him to be a starter, much less an effective starter...he's MAYBE going to be back in August in SOME capacity, Sept or '2026 if there is ANY issues. 

As for Cortes, should they be lucky enough to get him back and he's healthy(so the same thing that he went through last year)...you're going to just dump him? 

------
Now, onto the Nats. I don't know why they'd want an ace in a trade...other than...who doesn't want an ace. I want more aces. 

They have to be willing to pay for them. 

Which brings us to the return.

I'm fine with trading Peralta if you get an elite prospect for him. I'm not seeking out the team with the #4 3B prospect per MLB pipeline when we have the #6 and #7....neither of whom are Wilken and going after THAT trade. House has a 50% swing and miss rate at Fastballs out of the zone(43% overall). That's Keston Hiura again. 

 

To trade Peralta in the situation the Brewers are in, getting a LIFT from(not being carried by) young arms, you're going to need to be overwhelmed. 

 

So from the Nats, I'm going to want Sykora or Susana, House and maybe a Robert Hassell, see if we can get him back on track. 

And if I'm the Nats, I'm wondering why would I give up on a 3B who has big power when we could try and fix his swing and miss issues and then one of our potential TOR type arms AND a guy capable of being  great compliment to Wood and Crews in the OF if he can figure it out when we're 30-40 and out of the race. 

 

You really think they're paying going rate for a guy who may be the best arm on the market to what end? They're not a playoff team. 

 

Unless the Brewers fall out of the race, I'm not moving Peralta unless it's a guy like Emerson from Seattle or Walcott from the Rangers. 

The Brewers are finally bringing SS/3B prospects up. They have two guys who have 900+ OPS, 21 year old Luke Adams, he's got a .435 OBP, Bock Wilken, .390 with 16 HRs, then you have just a ton of guys the next two levels below who can play SS or 3rd. Cooper Pratt is also in AA, albeit a SS for now. Bitonti, I'm not sure if he can play 3B or if he just isn't because we had like 4 legit SS prospects on that team. But fine, most of them are further away. 

But I'll take my chances on keeping Peralta and hoping one of the bats we have coming up works out rather than trading Peralta for a guy with House' swing and miss issues(which I know Wilken and Adams have, but we're not giving anything up for them...and they have been BB rates). 

 

 

[Klantz27]

7 hours ago, BrewerFan said:

Miz is going to give you... maybe 60 more innings this year and while his stuff is electric, he's not a finished product.
Henderson, same thing, though he's over-performed. He's a good #3 who also has maybe 60-70 innings left. 

They could be pushed a bit, maybe 140, but they're not taking the ball every 5 days. 
 
Myers is in AAA because he wasn't throwing the ball well.
Patrick is throwing the ball well. Probably not wise to expect him to maintain this level of performance as a rookie and as HE gets closer to a career high in innings. 
Quintana was a cheap back of the rotation pitcher who is a nice innings filler.

Hall hasn't been a trust starter. Any plans to turn Ashby into one appear to be on hold for yet another year. 
Rodriguez...back of the rotation arm.

And Woodruff, I hope he comes back like Ashby did lsat year and is back to throwing 97 later in the year, but he hasn't started a game yet. 

Gasser won't be back as a starter this year. He may come back and pitching in some capacity, but expecting him to be a starter, much less an effective starter...he's MAYBE going to be back in August in SOME capacity, Sept or '2026 if there is ANY issues. 

As for Cortes, should they be lucky enough to get him back and he's healthy(so the same thing that he went through last year)...you're going to just dump him? 

------
Now, onto the Nats. I don't know why they'd want an ace in a trade...other than...who doesn't want an ace. I want more aces. 

They have to be willing to pay for them. 

Which brings us to the return.

I'm fine with trading Peralta if you get an elite prospect for him. I'm not seeking out the team with the #4 3B prospect per MLB pipeline when we have the #6 and #7....neither of whom are Wilken and going after THAT trade. House has a 50% swing and miss rate at Fastballs out of the zone(43% overall). That's Keston Hiura again. 

 

To trade Peralta in the situation the Brewers are in, getting a LIFT from(not being carried by) young arms, you're going to need to be overwhelmed. 

 

So from the Nats, I'm going to want Sykora or Susana, House and maybe a Robert Hassell, see if we can get him back on track. 

And if I'm the Nats, I'm wondering why would I give up on a 3B who has big power when we could try and fix his swing and miss issues and then one of our potential TOR type arms AND a guy capable of being  great compliment to Wood and Crews in the OF if he can figure it out when we're 30-40 and out of the race. 

 

You really think they're paying going rate for a guy who may be the best arm on the market to what end? They're not a playoff team. 

 

Unless the Brewers fall out of the race, I'm not moving Peralta unless it's a guy like Emerson from Seattle or Walcott from the Rangers. 

The Brewers are finally bringing SS/3B prospects up. They have two guys who have 900+ OPS, 21 year old Luke Adams, he's got a .435 OBP, Bock Wilken, .390 with 16 HRs, then you have just a ton of guys the next two levels below who can play SS or 3rd. Cooper Pratt is also in AA, albeit a SS for now. Bitonti, I'm not sure if he can play 3B or if he just isn't because we had like 4 legit SS prospects on that team. But fine, most of them are further away. 

But I'll take my chances on keeping Peralta and hoping one of the bats we have coming up works out rather than trading Peralta for a guy with House' swing and miss issues(which I know Wilken and Adams have, but we're not giving anything up for them...and they have been BB rates). 

 

 

[Klantz27]

Idc if the nats arent a playoff team i didn't make it there priority to acquire an ace 

Brady house is mlb ready we need 3b and ss now wilkens can barely hit 200 in double a cooper Pratt is ass and he is atleast 2 years out pena and made will be stars but there both probably 3 years out 

I'll take brady house all day long but who am I kidding we will trade peralta in the offseason for a bag of chips same with contreras 

[BrewerFan]

On 6/15/2025 at 4:02 PM, Klantz27 said:

Idc if the nats arent a playoff team i didn't make it there priority to acquire an ace 

Brady house is mlb ready we need 3b and ss now wilkens can barely hit 200 in double a

Yeah....AGAIN, every team wants an ace. The Nats want one for the FUTURE, that does not mean they're going to pay the asking price for Peralta at the deadline...and that price is in no way Brady House. A guy with an OBP of .359(vs Adams .435 or Wilken at .390).

House has a 30 Hit grade. A BABIP of just under .400. 

You're trading 1.5 years of an ace for a guy ONE year ahead of Wilken and Adams, both of whom were better, swing and miss less and walk a whole lot more than House.

Wilken has a WRC+ of 172, House of 126, Adams of 180

 

You're putting a WHOLE lot of faith in a guy having an abnormally good year after putting up poor BAs the last couple years because he's had half of a year with an extremely lucky BABIP.

LAST year he hit a .241 BA and a .297 OBP. That's be what you'd call "ass."
 

 

On 6/15/2025 at 4:02 PM, Klantz27 said:

a cooper Pratt is ass

Well... that's...brilliant. 

At 20, he's putting up a better line in AA than House did just a year ago

I hope we can continue to find prospects that "are ass" like Pratt! 

 

On 6/15/2025 at 4:02 PM, Klantz27 said:

I'll take brady house all day long but who am I kidding we will trade peralta in the offseason for a bag of chips same with contreras 

Yup! A bag of chips! Instead...we should do it in-season!

I kinda doubt we trade Contreras, but I can see given what a poorly run team we are, why you'd think that!

 

 

Can I ask, did you just look for a 3B with a good BA this year and then decide that's the player the Brewers have to trade for?

 

[Klantz27]

13 hours ago, BrewerFan said:

Yeah....AGAIN, every team wants an ace. The Nats want one for the FUTURE, that does not mean they're going to pay the asking price for Peralta at the deadline...and that price is in no way Brady House. A guy with an OBP of .359(vs Adams .435 or Wilken at .390).

House has a 30 Hit grade. A BABIP of just under .400. 

You're trading 1.5 years of an ace for a guy ONE year ahead of Wilken and Adams, both of whom were better, swing and miss less and walk a whole lot more than House.

Wilken has a WRC+ of 172, House of 126, Adams of 180

 

You're putting a WHOLE lot of faith in a guy having an abnormally good year after putting up poor BAs the last couple years because he's had half of a year with an extremely lucky BABIP.

LAST year he hit a .241 BA and a .297 OBP. That's be what you'd call "ass."
 

 

Well... that's...brilliant. 

At 20, he's putting up a better line in AA than House did just a year ago

I hope we can continue to find prospects that "are ass" like Pratt! 

 

Yup! A bad of chips! Instead...we should do it in-season!

I kinda doubt we trade Contreras, but I can see given what a poorly run team we are, why you'd think that!

 

 

Can I ask, did you just look for a 3B with a good BP this year and then decide that's the player the Brewers have to trade for?

 

Brady house was just called up ill make sure to come back to this post when he's tearing up the league 

And ill make sure to come back when cooper Pratt turns into Orlando arcia bunch of stupid stat watchers in this forum that's never watched any of these minor league guys play

[Brewer77]

1 hour ago, Klantz27 said:

Brady house was just called up ill make sure to come back to this post when he's tearing up the league 

And ill make sure to come back when cooper Pratt turns into Orlando arcia bunch of stupid stat watchers in this forum that's never watched any of these minor league guys play

Big Rochester Red Wings fan? Certainly you’ve been locked in on Brady House ABs all season if you’re talking like that

[liveforoctober]

1 hour ago, Klantz27 said:

Brady house was just called up ill make sure to come back to this post when he's tearing up the league 

And ill make sure to come back when cooper Pratt turns into Orlando arcia bunch of stupid stat watchers in this forum that's never watched any of these minor league guys play

The amazing thing about this interaction from a psychological standpoint is I'm certain you have interpreted this thread as "they all said Brady House is going to bust" and have assigned a group think reply to everyone here. So if he gets off to a good start you almost assuredly will come back here to tell us the vision you had for one of baseball's top 100 prospects and how wrong we all were.

[Klantz27]

1 hour ago, Brewer77 said:

Big Rochester Red Wings fan? Certainly you’ve been locked in on Brady House ABs all season if you’re talking like that

Ive been following abs to 171 prospects this year 😂 Brady house is on that list

[Klantz27]

1 hour ago, liveforoctober said:

The amazing thing about this interaction from a psychological standpoint is I'm certain you have interpreted this thread as "they all said Brady House is going to bust" and have assigned a group think reply to everyone here. So if he gets off to a good start you almost assuredly will come back here to tell us the vision you had for one of baseball's top 100 prospects and how wrong we all were.

I bet you will be happy with another joey ortiz type return for our ace Mr October how do you like watching these bums go one and out every October 

[BrewerFan]

11 hours ago, Klantz27 said:

Brady house was just called up ill make sure to come back to this post when he's tearing up the league 

And ill make sure to come back when cooper Pratt turns into Orlando arcia bunch of stupid stat watchers in this forum that's never watched any of these minor league guys play

Riight... bud, you're exclusively using stats to make ALL of your arguments. Yelich wasn't hitting well last year despite an OPS over .900 because...he didn't hit 20 HRs. He wasn't good the year before for that matter because he only had 19. 

In fact, that's been the sum total of your argument here for House. 

 

But, just to be clear, you watched Cooper Pratt and the comp you have is...Orlando Arcia...but you're saying nobody else watches these guys, just the stats! LOL...alright bud. 

 

Come back after House has 1500 PAs and give me an update. I suspect he's more  Keston Hiura than anything, but...sure.