Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Posted
1 hour ago, wildcat83 said:

You realize the owners are not going to let their own profit margins shrink right?  Higher payroll doesn't just mean bigger contracts for players.  It will come with increased prices for tickets, concessions, parking, etc. to make up the difference in profit.  Higher costs aren't absorbed by ownership, they are passed on to the customer.  When you combine that with the chance of fewer games, the cost to attend those fewer games is going to rise significantly.  

Thats not how businesses operate. They dont look at the contracts and say we need to charge more now. They figure out what the most they can charge while maintaining a healthy fanbase and optimize for that price. If the brewers could charge $1k average per seat today for a game, they would, but they wouldnt sell tickets that way. With $1k/ticket, they would then need to figure out how to run the most successful and efficient org possible to give the ticketholders what they paid for.

As for the cap, our views are skewed by recent success with the new moneyball. It's the most efficiently run FO in sports right now. But some are quick to forget the decades under Selig where there wasnt even hope for a winning record or any way out of the problem. If we were in the midst of the typical small market run, we'd be screaming bloody murder.

Unlike a normal free market scenario, this is a game. Part of the fun of a game is that everyone has a relatively equal chance to win and you optimize towards your strategy for success. That's a lot more fun for everyone and increases value for the entire game. If we started playing a game of monopoly and one guy starts with the 3 times the others every game, it wouldnt be very fun and people would grow tired of it quickly.

We dont know how long our FO edge will hold. Our FO and players have a spotlight on them and will continue to get poached. Teams are adjusting their strategies: the small market teams are optimizing like us now and the big market teams can rebuild quickly while being selective on which approaches to add. We have a nice window but after teams match us and this window closes, how will the brewers compete then?
 

Posted
19 hours ago, Matt said:

I think I'm the only person in Wisconsin who doesn't want a cap.

If the players ever did somehow agree to a cap, it would mean the owners gave up monumental concessions to the players, and just about all of them would be at the expense of well run teams like the Brewers. Quicker to free agency, quicker to Rule 5, Rule 5 options, standardized international facilities and rules, an international draft. The system that allows for the Brewers to be successful would be cratered. 

As nice as Milwaukee is in the summer, it'll absolutely never be a free agent destination when all other factors are equal. All a cap is going to do is increase the likelihood we lose our best players a year or two earlier because why sign a long term extension if you reach free agency in your mid-20s?

I'm also in the boat that doesn't necessarily think a hard cap is really needed.  People love to point to the NFL as the blue print.  I consider the NFL on field product to be garbage.  There does need to be some leveling of the on field payroll though.  MLB taking full control of the TV and media agreements and some sort of soft floor I think is necessary.  Teams tanking seasons and not spending what sharing is already in place competitively is a bigger issue than the high spenders.

I also have always appreciated the large vs small market type storylines that play out more than most.  It creates player trade dynamics and financial strategies that don't take place in other sports that I find make the overall industry and game more interesting to follow. 

As a fan there's really no side to take, imo. They both suck.  For the most part, the parties involved have no REAL financial interest in needing to resolve this quickly.  Many of them are pretty set for life or for seeable future financially so really it's just egos at the bargaining table.

The real push will have to come from the bottom half, financially of the PA and owners.  It's kind of how it works, nobody want to be the one to break rank and give an alternate opinion but I know not everyone is in agreement to what's being thrown out there now by the talking heads.

  • Like 1
Posted
2 hours ago, Team Canada said:

But that is only tenable if all teams have the same money to spend, so either it's revenue sharing, or cap, or both, but otherwise it just means the team with crazy TV deals will get the best players.

The teams have never all had the same money to spend and yet players have been paid what they're worth. So I don't agree. Any team can sign Shohei Ohtani to the contract he signed with the Dodgers and they'd be able to pay it. It's just that most other teams declined to do it or Ohtani really preferred to get a deal done specifically with the Dodgers. A salary cap is not required for teams to sign players they want to sign.

Posted

I think they should definitely do better with the revenue sharing, I think the Dodgers TV deal is probably as much money (or close) to what some organizations make across the board on everything. If they better revenue share I really don't care if the don't have a firm cap. I wouldn't mind keeping the taxpayer system a team goes over a certain amount, I do think mlb needs to better equalize the revenue. 

https://twinstrivia.com/2025/04/05/mlb-teams-revenue-versus-payroll/?scrlybrkr=9555d90d

I know sometimes these numbers are off because teams don't need to share finances however in 2024 if the Dodgers brought in $752 million (728 Yankees) and looking at CWS $277 that disparity is to big. Even the gap from the Dodgers/Yankees and a top 10 revenue team like San Fran $444 is to much. I would advocate that the teams that draw more fans and are successful should get more money but  the gap is to big. If money is spread around better than I do think that a floor needs to be put in. I think that the big thing here is that the smaller teams like the Brewers should be financially able to sign up to 3 stars long term. We really haven't been able to do more than 1 big long term commitment at a time for the life of the team. 

I feel like there is a lot they can do with changing some arbitration control and the pre-free agency ideas that will entice players to accept some major changes to the salary cap situation. I expect a holdout until like March and then a very expediated offseason and Spring Training, I am hopefully we won't miss any actual baseball.

Posted
1 hour ago, cragi said:

As for the cap, our views are skewed by recent success with the new moneyball. It's the most efficiently run FO in sports right now. But some are quick to forget the decades under Selig where there wasnt even hope for a winning record or any way out of the problem. If we were in the midst of the typical small market run, we'd be screaming bloody murder.

I think this was more a failure of the Selig family mindset more than an actual inability to be able to compete. The Seligs looked at the market disadvantage and gave up rather than try to find alternate ways to compete. They cried poor and then lived up to the restrictions they put on themselves. There wasn't a lot of investment in building actual success, they just went through the motions while adhering to traditional baseball talent acquisition from a poor team's perspective. Once Mark A arrived there was a near immediate turn around.

Posted
4 hours ago, MrTPlush said:

 

It’s all fine and dandy to be okay with the current system because the Brewers are at the peak of their existence, but someday that will end. 

That's debatable. Let's just keep winning the world series every year :-)

Posted
18 hours ago, Frisbee Slider said:

I think the point is the $180 million floor includes benefits, pension contributions, insurance for players, etc. More than just salary.

 

You are correct.  I saw a breakdown about 6 weeks ago.  The Brewers would only be forced to spend about another 8 million to reach that floor as I recall.

Posted
54 minutes ago, alwz4gbp said:

You are correct.  I saw a breakdown about 6 weeks ago.  The Brewers would only be forced to spend about another 8 million to reach that floor as I recall.

The flip side is if team payrolls currently used by the players union to show how small market teams arent paying players enough across the league actually had the full benefit/pension amounts included, most fans would look at those totals and wonder what the hell the players are complaining about in a sport that doesnt share revenues across the board

Posted

Eh it isn't that the players want to be paid more, it is they want more of the profit to be funneled to players instead of investors and private equity companies that own the teams now. And those investors want higher team valuations that controlled salary cap spending would bring so they can borrow massive amounts against team equity at little to no interest and minimized taxes.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...