Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Posted

There was little doubt that the Brewers would add Jett Williams, Luke Adams and Cameron Wagoner to their 40-man roster Tuesday. All three players would have been eligible to be selected in the Rule 5 Draft if they hadn't been added, and although the coming lockout might cancel that draft, anyway, the team wasn't willing to risk losing those players. All three would have been strong candidates to be selected in that draft, had it happened and had they been left exposed to it. All three have plausible roles on the 2027 Brewers.

As is often true with very deep organizations, though, Milwaukee also faced several closer calls ahead of Tuesday's deadline to protect players from the draft. They chose to add three more players whose likelihood of being picked was lower and whose long-term utility to the organization is less clear: catcher Matt Wood, second baseman Dylan O'Rae, and pitcher Tate Kuehner. That brought their 40-man list all the way to 40. It was a rare instance of a team with plenty of space on the roster suddenly filling it all.

In light of those calls, it's increasingly clear that change is coming later this week. Milwaukee now has four catchers on its 40-man roster, in William Contreras, Bo Naylor, Jeferson Quero and Wood. The chances of a Contreras trade this winter are remote, but so are the chances that the team sticks with all four of those guys all winter. It's more likely that they'll either non-tender Naylor on Friday. or trade Quero at some point soon. That's one way they can either re-open a spot on the 40-man (for instance, for a free-agent addition later on) or shift their resources to have a more balanced group.

Another player now on the chopping block was there all along, really. Tyler Black is almost certain to be waived or non-tendered and released outright this week. Though Adams (like Andrew Vaughn) bats right-handed and Black bats lefty, the Brewers have shown so little faith in the flash-in-the-pan former top prospect that it's almost impossible to imagine him lasting the winter on the 40-man list. He's out of options and can't be sent to the minors next spring without being offered to the other 29 teams, anyway. 

There are smaller chances of what would be bigger moves. Vaughn could be non-tendered, which might spare Black's roster spot. Trevor Megill (almost sure to be dealt sometime this winter) could be traded, opening a 40-man spot. However, the only moves with any real urgency to them are removing one of the catchers and disposing of Black. The Brewers' collection of optionable pitchers is one of the most enviable in the league. Megill is the only pitcher on the 40-man roster who can't be sent freely to the minors next year (though, in practice, several of them won't be). For that matter, the only position players in that predicament are Contreras, Christian Yelich, Vaughn and Black. For a World Series champion to have such roster flexibility is almost unheard of, but that's where the Brewers stand. They can, if they so choose, have a very quiet winter and still be a well-balanced, robust candidate to make another deep run into October next season.

Image courtesy of Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images

View full article

Recommended Posts

Posted

Just thinking off the cuff, but with that many established players having options is there an angle where they might look at burning an option instead of a short DL stint? AKA go sit on the AAA bench for a week to heal something up, so we aren't a man down?

  • Like 1
Posted
15 minutes ago, igor67 said:

Just thinking off the cuff, but with that many established players having options is there an angle where they might look at burning an option instead of a short DL stint? AKA go sit on the AAA bench for a week to heal something up, so we aren't a man down?

I'm sure the player and the player's association would have an issue with that.  For the pre-arb guys that is a big salary discrepancy between the majors and minors.  Plus, the player would not be accruing any MLB service time.

Plus, when they place a player on the IL, it opens up an active roster spot.

  • Like 1
Posted

I almost have to believe there are other moves pending.  Looks like an overkill protecting so many players.

Posted

What is the scouting report on Wood's defense?  He seems to be the type of patient hitter that fits the Brewer profile.  I know Quero was the consensus heir apparent at C.  But his injuries are concerning.

Posted
1 hour ago, igor67 said:

Just thinking off the cuff, but with that many established players having options is there an angle where they might look at burning an option instead of a short DL stint? AKA go sit on the AAA bench for a week to heal something up, so we aren't a man down?

I'm not sure what you are trying to gain out of this. 40 man roster during the offseason doesn't reflect MiLB options or injuries (60, 15 or 10 day IL stints). It is just 40 poeple allowed on the list regardless of status.

If you are thinking 26 man during year active roster, the BP should have spots. There are really only 6 of the 8 BP spots that are locks in Uribe, Ashby, DLH, Anderson, Walker, Patrick, 

This assumes Drohan/Sproat is in rotation (either AAA or MLB), Megill is traded, and Zepra isn't back until mid-season from injury. 

 

  • Like 1
Posted
1 hour ago, Opening Day said:

What is the scouting report on Wood's defense?  He seems to be the type of patient hitter that fits the Brewer profile.  I know Quero was the consensus heir apparent at C.  But his injuries are concerning.

Wood is hit over power profile. He makes a lot of contact, has good swing decisions, and generally has good angles/pull characteristics. His EVs are good not great. His arm is fringe average (likely below average), but his receiving/pitch calling/blocking really took a step forward so he is now probably comfortably average there outside of the arm.

His 99% outcome is Liam Hicks if you are looking for a comp.

What made Quero the heir apparent was excellent defense led by a 80 grade arm. The arm is now more fringe average and more of a hindrance than a help. Also concerning is the rest of the defense also has not really been as great since coming back from the shoulder injury. Basically the defense that was so amazing it could carry the rest no matter the hitting is now below average and the bat is going to have to carry the profile.

This would have seemed crazy to me 2 years ago (prior to Quero shoulder injury), but in my mind they have flipped and I'm higher on Wood than Quero.

  • Like 2
Posted

It's hard to emotionally give up on prospects whom you've been rooting for for years, but I wish Black well. Hope he becomes a major leaguer elsewhere.  I would hope Quero at least merits some trade return. 

  • Like 2
Posted
18 minutes ago, keephopealive said:

It's hard to emotionally give up on prospects whom you've been rooting for for years, but I wish Black well. Hope he becomes a major leaguer elsewhere.  I would hope Quero at least merits some trade return. 

Same. Even coming into this year I still had hope for Black in the OF (even if it wasn't with Milwaukee). I was hoping you could trade him to a rebuilding team for a Victor Vodik/Seth Halverson type of boom or bust RP. Now I think you trade him for whatever lotto ticket you can get bc a DFA is coming.

  • Like 2
Posted
1 hour ago, Spaul194 said:

I'm not sure what you are trying to gain out of this. 40 man roster during the offseason doesn't reflect MiLB options or injuries (60, 15 or 10 day IL stints). It is just 40 poeple allowed on the list regardless of status.

If you are thinking 26 man during year active roster, the BP should have spots. There are really only 6 of the 8 BP spots that are locks in Uribe, Ashby, DLH, Anderson, Walker, Patrick, 

This assumes Drohan/Sproat is in rotation (either AAA or MLB), Megill is traded, and Zepra isn't back until mid-season from injury. 

 

Definitely an in season thought. I was wondering if there were some advantages to optioning a guy who has a minor injury that might need 3-7 days off. We often get frustrated by those stretches when we are playing a man down.  A lot of our guys are now into arbitration or have MLB contracts, which might lessen some of those issues. And if you option a guy they can come back up sooner than 10 days if there is another injury as I recall.

Posted

In hindsight, O'Rae is the infield version of Sal but he takes more walks and has stolen more bases. I am glad we did protect him, Wood is similar a Brewers ideal more walks than k's bat. We saw the upside to Kuehner in 2025, protecting him is surprising but not unforeseen. I could see him being a starter next year and being a guy who transitions to the bullpen/multi-inning role if there aren't injuries.

Black is likely as good as gone, I wouldn't be surprised if we keep Naylor at least .through Spring training. I would think we let Quero, Naylor, and Wood compete for the backup and trading Naylor or Quero wouldn't be very difficult mid-spring if there is a clear winner.

Posted

Thanks Matthew! 

I was curious why there seems to be a stress point on releasing some guys soon? Wouldn't the team have players in mind but not necessarily release them until their spot is needed? 

Posted

In some cases I think teams wait until right after the Rule V to drop some players to take advantage of the fact that other teams just filled their 40-mans so there is less of a chance of those dropped players signing elsewhere.

Posted

(speaking on Black) "it's almost impossible to imagine him lasting the winter on the 40-man list." 

Two sentences later... 

"Vaughn could be non-tendered, which might spare Black's roster spot."

Made me laugh. Not disagreeing with anything you wrote, just funny you imagined a way to keep Black so quickly after calling it unimaginable :) Good read, thanks!

Posted
1 hour ago, jay87shot said:

In hindsight, O'Rae is the infield version of Sal but he takes more walks and has stolen more bases. I am glad we did protect him,

Sal was a significantly better prospect. He had a better hit tool (70) and more power (40-45) as a prospect. Sal had a .313/.393/.455/.848 slash line with 45 steals (14 CS) before they tweaked the SB rules in about 1.5 years of PAs in the minors. 30 SBs/season back then is a lot more impressive than 50 today.  If I remember correctly, Sal was a top 50 (maybe even top 25) prospect in all of baseball when he graduated. O'Rae wasn't on Brewers top 10 when BA released their updated list and will likely be borderline to be on Brewers top 30.

Current Sal (in terms of career production/averages) is likely a higher outcome than O'Rae's ceiling which is more a 2B/OF version of David Hamilton though not quite that much speed.

Posted
1 hour ago, Spaul194 said:

Sal was a significantly better prospect. He had a better hit tool (70) and more power (40-45) as a prospect. Sal had a .313/.393/.455/.848 slash line with 45 steals (14 CS) before they tweaked the SB rules in about 1.5 years of PAs in the minors. 30 SBs/season back then is a lot more impressive than 50 today.  If I remember correctly, Sal was a top 50 (maybe even top 25) prospect in all of baseball when he graduated. O'Rae wasn't on Brewers top 10 when BA released their updated list and will likely be borderline to be on Brewers top 30.

Current Sal (in terms of career production/averages) is likely a higher outcome than O'Rae's ceiling which is more a 2B/OF version of David Hamilton though not quite that much speed.

Yes, Sal was a much higher ranked prospect but O'Rae is just in that mold. Sal had/has more power and consistentcy at all levels. O'Rae has had issues but just overall has the Sal type griddy, small player, grinder aspect that has been successful for us.

Posted

Anyone else look at the Seattle/KC trade and think. That is a weird one.

Seattle sent RHP Bryce Miller, LHP Jose Ferrer and RHP Logan Evans to Kansas City in exchange for 3B Maikel Garcia, RHP James McArthur and RHP L.P. Langevin

Seattle needs an OF and traded for a SS/3B. For Seattle this means Colt Emerson/Maikel Garcia at SS/3B and moves Donovan to the OF. KC kind of needs everything and just traded their 2nd or 3rd most talented player.

Posted

This trade fixes 1 issue for the Mariners but they project as negative defenders at all 3 OF positions. Fangraphs depth charts has Canzone and Raley in the corner OFs. Both would be better at DH at this point. They still need a RH corner OF, and likely a defense first CF. I'm sure they'd love to have a Lara or even a Lockridge type as an option (their lineup is overly LH). 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...