Braun named Rookie of the Year in closest NL vote ever

[DannoMac21]

Rookie of the Years will be named tomorrow, and at the end of SportsCenter the host said "Dustin Pedoria and Ryan Braun to win them."

 

Congratulations to Braun if true.

[SeriesFinale]

It won't be announced until 1 PM CST...if that's what eh said then he's just guessing

[chadomac]

He didn't say that that's who was going to win, he said that's who he guessed was going to win... and then the other guy agreed with him. I just saw that, too.

[RU Rah Rah]

Would it be a blessing in disguise if he lost because of his defense? Would he get a chip on his shoulder and set out to prove everybody wrong?

(Not saying that I want him to lose, though.)

[PeaveyFury]

About time they got around to the awards- it seems like they're dragging this out forever.

 

Have they seriously waited until the third week after the WS to announce the awards before?

[Fatter than Joey]

Have they seriously waited until the third week after the WS to announce the awards before?

 

Yeah -- and they name one award a day.

 

I have always thought they did it to stay on everyone's radar, when the sports world is focused on NBA and NFL

[dlk9s]

Would it be a blessing in disguise if he lost because of his defense? Would he get a chip on his shoulder and set out to prove everybody wrong?

(Not saying that I want him to lose, though.)

Nah. He realizes his fielding was sub-par.

 

[Jim Goulart]

Braun wins -- JS Coverage

[jlau20]

It's official. Awesome. Congrats Ryan, now it's your turn Prince.

[YutakaEnatsu]

It's offiical - congrats to Ryan. He beat out Tulowitzski by 2 points, according to mlb.com.

[mattmieske]

Who the heck picked Braun third? And who could have received the other second place vote? I can't see anyone honestly thinking Chris Young or Josh Hamilton had a better year than Braun, even with his fielding problems.

[squambaum]

Who the heck picked Braun third? And who could have received the other second place vote? I can't see anyone honestly thinking Chris Young or Josh Hamilton had a better year than Braun, even with his fielding problems.

per rotoworld kyle kendrick received the only top two vote that did not go to braun or tulo. It would be interesting to see if the writer who voted for kendrick came from the colorado market.

 

[brwrsfan]

Any bets that a Colorado writer put Braun third?? I certainly hope thats not the case but it wouldn't surprise me. Trying to help out his own guy....I can't see any way that someone could actually believing Braun was the third best rookie...either way, woohoo for Ryan Braun!!

[Jim Goulart]

If Braun and Tulo had split the first-place vote, that third-place vote would've made the difference, with Braun missing out.

[Fatter than Joey]

wow -- that's awesome -- move over Pat Listach

[craigharmann]

Congrats to Braunie! Just as long as his career is better than Pat Listach's, I'll be happy. It would be awesome if Prince pulls out MVP, but we've got one of the fall awards wrapped up! Awesome stuff!

[TooLiveBrew]

Congratulations, Ryan! This is awesome. Yea, I'd guess that a Col. sportswriter threw in that 3rd place vote. I could never compromise my integrity on that one, personally - if I wanted to vote Tulo first, fine - but no way I'd try to submarine another deserving candidate. Who was that sportswriter from Denver who wrote the whiny 'Tulo should win because Braun isn't good on defense' (trust me, the article was even worse than it sounds - my 'title' sounds noteworthy) piece? I'd bet on him.

[PrinceFielder28]

Congrats Braun!

[PrinceFielder28]

When is MVP announced?

[LouisEly]

In terms of production, home and away, Braun was much more consistent that Tulowitzki, who batted .326 with 15 home runs and 60 RBI in 77 games at Coors Field, compared to a .256 average, nine homers and 39 RBI in 78 games on the road.

 

Braun posted nearly identical numbers, home and away, batting .326 with 17 homers, 49 RBI and a .660 slugging percentage in 56 games at Miller Park, and .322 with 17 homers, 48 RBI and a .610 slugging percentage in 57 games on the road.

 

There's your difference, and justification, right there.

[splitterpfj]

This was the correct choice. I love Tulowitzki, and he would have been a worthy recipient, but what Braun did with the bat is simply amazing.

 

I really don't think most people have realized how absolutely incredible Braun's performance was - this was not really good - this level of success is how legends are made. Yes, the defense needed to be taken into account, but so did Tulo's home/road splits, which are also glaring.

 

Two great young players - the next time a guy like Hamelin or Hollandsworth wins this award...remember years like this one.

[craigharmann]

Gotta love ESPN radio...in their update, they're going on about Tulowitski, and then they say that "in a mild surprise", Ryan Braun is voted ROY. Just wait until next year and they're FORCED to give the Brew Crew some love!

[pretendastronaut]

I don't see how anyone cannot question the Colorado writer. The way the numbers play out he'd been anyone's first guess. It would be a shame if it was true, but it probably won't become a big issue seeing as Braun still won.

 

Congrats to Ryan.

[jwaltz]

Both guys were deserving and in other years Tulo would have ran away with it but Braun was the correct choice. Yes, Tulo's defense is much better but Tulo's road struggles negate a good amount of that. For half his games he was just adequate offensively. That has to be taken into account.

[zachlaka]

Awesome news way to go Braun. He even won without being up in the majors April and most of May http://forum.brewerfan.net/images/smilies/smile.gif

 

The Brewers should do a season ticket holder ROY bobblehead set for this.