There was one thread that turned into a big debate, where that was discussed. Can't remember which one. I think the best way to look at it is the $ value is what the production, not the player, was worth. It's too bad that Kapler re-signed with the Rays, since he'd have been a perfect fit if the Brewers decide not to retain Cameron. Please don't decide to do that, Brewers. I am, however, glad that Gabe's decision to return to playing has worked out so well for him. I wonder why he decided to retire in the first place. EDIT: Found some interesting quotes from Gabe... this one from his Wikipedia page, on why he went to play for the Yomiuri Giants in 2005: And on his retirement in 2006: